Will AI Replace Your Creative Team?

In the church and ministry world, you’ve probably heard some level of this question: Can AI replace our designer?

Jordan Wiseman

Jordan Wiseman

FOUNDER + CREATIVE DIRECTOR

In the church and ministry world, you’ve probably heard some level of this question: Can AI replace our designer?

Quite frankly, some leaders are asking it hopefully, wishing for a smaller budget. Creatives are probably asking it apprehensively, wondering if their future is at risk.

My honest answer: Can AI replace your church’s designer? Probably. But should it? I think that’s a different question.

And the difference between those two questions matters more for the Church than anywhere else.

Yes, but …

Here’s the thing: AI can generate a sermon series graphic in seconds. It can write a caption, resize a graphic for six platforms, and produce a dozen logo concepts before your coffee cools.

And for a lot of ministries with limited budgets, that’s tempting. Design is expensive, and good designers can be hard to find.

If your only goal is to generate a lot of content, well, AI can probably do some of that.

But that alone was never the goal. We have to make sure we’re creating the right things for the right audience.

AI can’t love people

Something I’ve come to believe: the best creative work takes skill, but it starts with love for people.

When a designer chooses a photo or a copywriter writes a headline, they’re also deciding what to leave out.

Just one example: Loving people well might mean making sure the photography on your website shows the range of people God is bringing to your church. A guest is going to notice when they don’t see anyone like them. AI won’t catch that nuance, but someone who knows and loves your church will.

This view of creativity isn’t new. In Exodus 31, God tells Moses that He has chosen Bezalel and filled him with the Spirit of God to make artistic designs for the Tabernacle. He’s actually one of the first people Scripture describes as filled with the Spirit, and it’s for his craftsmanship and creativity.

God cares about beauty. He filled the world with it, and as His people, our creative work is meant to reflect that care. And care is something that only humans can truly give.

AI doesn’t know your community

AI can learn a lot about the world, but it doesn’t know your city or your neighborhood.

This matters because great work is precise. It’s the right word for the right person. AI is built to predict the most likely answer, which means it pulls toward the average.

Your ministry can’t afford to sound average.

AI doesn’t know the school down the street just closed, that half of your neighborhood works blue-collar jobs, or the challenges your community is carrying. A church or ministry that’s planted in a place knows that.

Your audience is specific people with specific stories, and God has called you to them.

People can tell when it’s AI … and they don’t love it

There’s a phrase that Gen Z is using more and more: “That’s AI.” It’s rarely (never?) a compliment.

Younger audiences grew up surrounded by technology, and they’re experts at spotting content generated by a machine instead of made by a person. When they see it, it often comes across as cheap or impersonal. They keep scrolling, and you lose trust. And for a ministry inviting people to the greatest story ever, that’s a pretty costly first impression.

People can tell when something was made for them. And they can tell when it wasn’t.

Where AI works

By this point, it might seem like I’m anti-AI, and truthfully, I’m really not. I’m using these tools in some form almost every day.

And none of this means that AI has no place on your team. It might just be a different place than most people think.

What creatives and strategists do best is think. They understand the audience, find the right idea, and cut whatever is just noise.

What slows creative people down is busywork, and that’s where AI shines.

A designer might create a strong piece of art, then use AI to adapt and resize it for every platform. Or a writer might draft the announcement, then use AI to shape it into a caption, an email, or website copy that still uses their own words.

Here’s the rule of thumb I’d suggest: Human first draft, AI second. Let people do the hard work of thinking, and let AI help with the formatting, resizing, and repurposing.

If you’re leading the team

If you’re a senior or executive leader with a creative team in your organization, here are three things to be thinking about when it comes to AI:

  1. Look at where the team’s hours are going. How much time is spent thinking and creating, and how much is spent on resizing, reformatting, or chasing approvals?

  2. Hand the busywork to AI. Give your team permission and a few good tools to automate the repetitive parts.

  3. Protect time to think. Use the hours you and your team get back to understand your people better: listening, visiting, and asking better questions.

The goal isn’t to have fewer creatives. It’s to have creatives who spend most of their time on work only they can do.

A good brand connects

The best brands connect with people. And you can’t connect well with people you don’t know or love.

That’s why I started Goodwise. We want to partner with churches and ministries to understand their community and their goals, then bring that to life with creative as strong as the mission.

AI can help speed up the process, but it takes people who know and love your community to make sure the work lands well.

—

If this was helpful, subscribe to Good & Wise, our monthly note for leaders who serve the Church. Interested in working with Goodwise on a project? Schedule a call, and let’s chat.

THE GOOD & WISE NEWSLETTER

Good ideas for teams who serve the Church.

Once a month, practical thinking on messaging, brand, and creative, plus the newest posts from the blog. Short, useful, and easy to put to work.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

THE GOOD & WISE NEWSLETTER

Good ideas for teams who serve the Church.

Once a month, practical thinking on messaging, brand, and creative, plus the newest posts from the blog. Short, useful, and easy to put to work.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

THE GOOD & WISE NEWSLETTER

Good ideas for teams who serve the Church.

Once a month, practical thinking on messaging, brand, and creative, plus the newest posts from the blog. Short, useful, and easy to put to work.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

Keep reading.

Let’s create something good together.

Tell us about your mission, your team, and what’s falling behind. We’ll help you find the clearest next step.

Let’s create something good together.

Tell us about your mission, your team, and what’s falling behind. We’ll help you find the clearest next step.

Let’s create something good together.

Tell us about your mission, your team, and what’s falling behind. We’ll help you find the clearest next step.